Due process is inevitably amongst the first casualties during moral panics or emergencies. Salem hanged witches, Lincoln jailed journalists, and Newsom arrested paddleboarders. But usually those suspensions of civil liberties are circumscribed in time. The witch hunt ends, the war concludes, the mania fades.
The Western myth of rape culture, however, is unique in its unceasing assault on the central tenets of due process. Through the entrenchment of this permanent psychosis, the Anglosphere abandons the right to confront witnesses, the presumption of innocence, the denial of hearsay, and the consideration of statements against interest. That legal vacuum allows for the weaponization of justice against dissenters, sordid career advancement, and a political culture premised on sensationalized falsehoods.
This month, Russell Brand was sentenced to over a decade in prison for supposedly “raping” women over 20 years ago. The trial allowed the purported victims to recreate phone exchanges from memory, featured a lengthy analysis of whether Mr. Brand grabbed a woman’s breasts in 2004, and considered whether Mr. Brand attempted to coerce a woman into a bathroom stall in 2001. The entire case was devoid of physical evidence, and the charges only came after Channel 4 and the Sunday Times (owned by NewsCorp and Rupert Murdoch) released a “documentary” in which hired actresses portrayed unverified accounts of Brand committing sexual assault.
The reasonable doubt in the Brand trial is undeniable. The prosecution offered no forensic evidence, DNA tests, or CCTV footage. The testimony was the product of memories of over 20 years that frequently changed to suit the narrative of the post-“documentary” era. For example, one “victim” originally told friends that Brand had made unwanted advances on her at a bar, but she had escaped before anything occurred. Then, after seeing the Times documentary, she told the police that Mr. Brand dragged her into a toilet (in front of the crowded bar) and raped her.
But in the believe-all-women exception to due process, the court chastised Mr. Brand’s counsel for cross-examining the accusers. Justice Bennathan scolded Brand, “all those women had to face being confronted and being told they had lied or twisted the truth and, or, they had agreed to your sexual demands: that was all done because of you, on your instructions.” He later denounced Mr. Brand’s “staggering arrogance” and “dreadful behavior.”
Bennathan’s attack on Brand’s right to defend himself was not limited to suggesting he should have forfeited his right to cross-examination. From the bench, he decided to “pay tribute to the determination and bravery of all the women whose evidence I have been recounting.” But despite their “bravery,” Bennathan reminded the press that there “is a strict legal prohibition on making public the names of any of the women complainants.”
Then, when Brand restated his innocence following his conviction, the British government announced that it was “urgently” investigating him for further charges for “causing distress to victims.”
Taken as a whole, the case is a profound miscarriage of justice. Russell Brand went from serving as a darling of liberal society to a sworn enemy of the ruling class due to his opposition to Covid lockdowns and his conversion to Christianity.
When hit pieces failed to diminish his influence – one scathing piece alarmingly reported that Brand “dangerously flouted social distancing rules by taking selfies with swathes of fans and even hugging one” in 2020 – the weaponization of justice began.
Using the cloak of anonymity, the largest media forces in the world helped concoct a mass hysteria in which parties that admitted to having consensual sex with Brand accused him of sexual assault approximately two decades after their conjugal dalliances.
The judge allowed the witnesses to reconstruct text messages from memory from before the age of the iPhone – permitting them to come up with any unverified discussion they wanted – but attacked Brand for mounting a defense. It remains illegal for the press to report on the accusers, and now Brand is sentenced to prison until 2037.
Governments now know that feminist rhetoric is an effective cover for them to cudgel their opponents into silence. Easily debunked sexual assault accusations sparked over a decade of captivity for Julian Assange. But that tactic is not limited to the surveillance state.
The Cornell Seven debacle demonstrates that the same forces usurping due process pave the way for manipulation by private actors through civil lawsuits. There, the evidence supporting the innocence of the accused is overwhelming. The purported victim repeatedly told her friends and the local police that the interaction was consensual.
When rumors circulated on campus of her orgiastic escapades, she texted friends that “everyone needs to grow up” because “sexuality and sex…is changing.” She messaged one of the accused “rapists,” “At the end of the day none of the sexual stuff was illegal and honestly i really liked being w u and Matt.” She followed up with the accused rapists that they should not feel any guilt about their tryst because it was “our body our choice.”
Her attitude changed when there were social ramifications for the group’s bacchanalian frolics. She was eager to attend the Halloween party at the fraternity house where she later claimed to be raped. But when she was uninvited amidst rumors about the libidinous congregation, she wrote to her former sex partners, “I knew this was going to happen. The woman will always get the short end of the stick. Y’all aren’t my friends. Y’all are covering your asses.”
The following month, she went to local law enforcement with a six-page sworn statement. The local district attorney declined to pursue charges, concluding that she “did not allege that she was drugged against her will or gang-raped” and instead described her participation in drug use and sexual conduct as “voluntary, conscious, and consensual.”
But then the purported victim hired a personal injury attorney from New York City and an insurance lawyer from Alabama to monetize her story. They did not just bring claims against the seven Cornell students. Instead, they targeted Cornell University (endowment of $13.6 billion), Chi Phi Fraternity, Inc. (which lists $2.25 million in assets), Delta Delta Delta Sorority ($28 million in assets), and local companies. By whipping up a media frenzy, they sought to capitalize on public hysteria by pressuring these institutions into making multimillion dollar settlement payments.
All the men have been named publicly, and some have been fired from their jobs. Their futures are tarnished, and a ravenous news media and political system repeat vacuous slogans cheering their demise.
New York Attorney General Letitia James already asserted the guilt of the accused, writing “What this young woman has been forced to endure is horrific and unacceptable.” Similarly, New York Governor Kathy Hochul told the press conclusively that the accuser had “endured something that is utterly unspeakable” and was “failed at every turn by people and institutions with an obligation to protect her.” Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) told followers, “Seven men drugged and gang raped a 20-year-old woman.”
The evidence clearly repudiates their assertions and exonerates the accused. But the system is rigged to expose the seven men to reputational and financial ruin while their accuser enjoys the privilege of anonymity and the prospect of millions of dollars in settlement payments.
Like the United Kingdom, the United States features “rape shield” laws and anonymity protections that allow accusers to remain insulated from public scrutiny or cross-examination questions about their pasts in criminal cases. This is anathema to the Sixth Amendment of the United States Constitution and its Confrontation Clause.
In Crawford v. Washington, the late Justice Antonin Scalia wrote “the only indicium of reliability sufficient to satisfy constitutional demands is the one the Constitution actually prescribes: confrontation.” Yet the permanent moral panic prohibits fulfillment of those constitutional demands in sexual assault cases.
Instead, we get a system of kangaroo courts and media lynchings, giving rise to attorneys like Michael Avenatti, accusers like Julie Swetnick, journalists like Sabrina Erdely at Rolling Stone, and actual victims like the Duke lacrosse team.
The protections of anonymity and the eradication of due process rest on false premises and create incentives misaligned with justice. They assume that the accusers are undoubtedly truthful and accurate when studies show that up to 40% of rape cases involve false accusations and our recent cultural memory includes headlines of Tawana Brawley in New York, Crystal Mangum at Duke, and “Jackie” at the University of Virginia.
The Cornell accuser and her attorneys can warp the legal system to their advantage, and the result is the persecution of seven young men.
Justice Louis Brandeis wrote, “Men feared witches and burnt women. It is the function of speech to free men from the bondage of irrational fears.” But our legal system has codified the bondage of hysteria in the rape context. If reform does not occur, the abuse will only continue.
Join the Conversation
Published under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
For reprints, please set the canonical link back to the original Brownstone Institute Article and Author.







